You’re ready to plant when you score green on all ten red flags assessors look for: recruiting, asking, marriage, money, preaching, likability, an honorable exit, integrity, fit for the city and self-starting drive. Yellow on any of them means not yet, and red means planting isn’t your best fit.
Assess yourself before anyone else does
Before a network hands you money, it’s going to assess you. Before you put your family on the line, you should assess yourself first.
Networks that give more money assess more strictly, and that makes sense. They’re making an investment, and an investment needs a return. A network putting real dollars behind your plant wants to know you can grow a church that lasts.
When I was assessed through ARC, there were ten interviews, and about half of the 40 candidates were cut by day two. That’s what a serious assessment looks like. The people running it had seen what happens when someone who isn’t ready plants anyway.
Good assessment is a gift. It confirms that your sense of calling is real, and it shows you where you need to grow before you plant, while the cost of growing is still low. So do the hard work now, on paper.
Green, yellow or red
Your assessment will land you in one of three places:
- Green means go now. Everything is aligned and there are no red flags. You can lead, preach, fundraise, recruit, lead an organization and cast vision. Start planning.
- Yellow means not yet. You have real gaps, and they can be fixed. Work on them, or find a better scenario to plant from. Yellow is a timing answer.
- Red means planting isn’t the best fit for you. That’s not the end of your ministry. There are plenty of other kingdom teams to serve on, and many great leaders serve best on one of them.
Most planters are yellow in at least one area. That’s normal. The danger is pretending you’re green when you’re yellow, or ignoring a red flag because you really want to plant.
The ten red flags
Read each one slowly and score yourself honestly: green, yellow or red. Better yet, ask your wife and your lead pastor to score you too, and compare.
- You can’t grow a group past 10 or recruit 20 to 30 people. To launch large you’ll need 125 to 200 adults on your pre-launch team. If you’ve never grown a small group past ten or recruited 20 to 30 people into anything, that’s a red flag. Simple test: can you throw a party and get 100 people there? The best planters often throw the best parties, which is why startup parties sit at the center of a large launch.
- You’re bad at making asks. Planting is asking, all day, every day: to join, to give, to host, to lead, to invite a friend. James puts it bluntly: “You do not have, because you do not ask” (James 4:2, ESV). If you hint and hope instead of asking clearly, you’ll come up short on people and money.
- Your marriage isn’t secure or aligned. Is there strife right now? Is your wife fully on board, or will she second-guess the decision every time it gets hard? Planting will expose every crack. If your marriage isn’t strong, stop here and work on that first.
- Your finances are a mess. Heavy debt, high monthly payments, poor credit, no emergency fund. You’re about to ask hundreds of people to trust you with their giving. If you can’t manage your own household’s money, that’s a red flag for you and for them.
- Your preaching rates under 5 out of 10. The sermon is one of the primary growth engines of a new church. If honest listeners would put you under a 5, people won’t come back, and they won’t invite their friends.
- You’re not likable. This one stings. Would your lead pastor personally underwrite a $100K matching loan for you? Are you divisive? Do people leave conversations with you feeling better or worse? People follow leaders they like and trust.
- You left your last role dishonorably. Were you a son of the house, honoring your leader all the way out? Or are you planting with a chip on your shoulder because you think you could do it better than the last guy? Planting out of offense poisons the new church from the start. Networks will call your last lead pastor.
- You have unaddressed secret sin or addiction. David shepherded Israel with an upright heart (Psalm 78:72): the same man in public and in private. Secret sin, including pornography or any addiction, will come out under the pressure of planting. Deal with it now, with real accountability.
- You’re a poor fit for the city. Language, accent and culture matter. People are tribal, and they connect more easily with leaders who feel like them. Ask honestly whether you’re the best fit to reach this group. Choosing your city starts with that question.
- You’re not a self-starter. Nobody will hand you a schedule. Entrepreneurs wake up knowing their high-priority tasks for the day, and they execute. If you need a boss to keep you moving, a planter’s calendar will eat you alive.
Notice what’s on the list
Every flag is a competency or a character issue you can see and measure: recruiting, asking, marriage, money, preaching, likability, honor, integrity, fit and drive.
Feelings aren’t on the list. Wanting to plant badly isn’t on the list. Feeling frustrated where you are isn’t on the list either. Desire matters, and the call matters most of all, but networks and sending churches assess what they can observe, and so should you.
Questions to ask yourself
Work through these honestly, and preferably with your wife:
- Has God called me? Start here. Everything else is secondary.
- Is it a knowledge gap or a skill gap? Reading, training and coaching close a knowledge gap. A skill gap, like preaching or recruiting, takes reps and time.
- Is it the right idea at the wrong time? Many planters are called and simply early.
- Should I parachute in and fundraise, or be sent and seeded by a church?
- Am I running from something? A bad current situation doesn’t make planting better. A year in, you may wish you were back on that staff.
The yellow path to green
Yellow can turn green. It takes intention and time. Here are the most common moves:
- Find a sending church. Ask a strong church to take you on staff for one to four years, long enough to fix your yellow flags. A church that trusts you at the end can send you and back you, or underwrite a loan for your plant. This one path builds honor, sharpens skills and gives you a sponsor.
- Fix your preaching. Preach every chance you get, record yourself and watch the tape. Fix one thing at a time.
- Reset your finances. Give yourself a couple of years to pay down debt, build an emergency fund and get your credit in order.
- Build your fundraising muscle. If you’ve never raised money, start practicing now.
- Lengthen your runway. If your network is small, give yourself three years of preparation instead of one, and use that time to build a war chest. Money raised years ahead must be returned if the plant doesn’t happen, so be clear with donors from the start.
For lead pastors who send planters
If you have a potential planter on your team, this list is for you too. You know things about him no assessment weekend will uncover. You’ve watched him recruit for your events. You’ve seen how he handles money, how he talks about his wife and how he responds when you tell him no.
Walk through the ten flags with him, one at a time, and be specific. “Your preaching is a 6, and here’s the one thing that would make it a 7” helps him far more than “you’re doing great.” If you see a red flag, say so now, in private, while there’s still time to fix it.
Then ask yourself the question from red flag 6: would you personally underwrite his plant? If the honest answer is no, he’s not green yet. Tell him what it would take to get to yes, and help him get there. That’s what a church father does.
A network that loves you will tell you no
Some networks are loose. They’ll approve almost anyone, because they want to count one more plant. That might feel like encouragement. Approving everyone isn’t love. When you’re weighing which network to plant with, a strict assessment is a point in its favor.
A network that loves you will tell you no, or at least not yet.
A no or a not yet from a network that knows what it’s doing can save your family, your finances and years of your life. Take it seriously, and use it to grow.
Score all ten flags in writing this week. Get your wife’s scorecard and your lead pastor’s, and compare them without arguing. For every yellow, write one concrete step and a date. Launch Large takes you from there to the plan, the team and the money.
